Volume Three · Season One: Encountering Crowds, Apprehending Clouds
A Meta-Cast by Intend to Relate
- Episode Two

An authorial reflection on mediated intimacy, asymmetrical knowledge, and the difference between receiving a work and acquiring a relationship with its creator.

Episode guide · Full transcript

Watch or listen

To Them — Episode Two

Original Version: Spotify · Apple · Youtube

On one side of the lens, a person appears to be speaking directly to you. On the other side, the person speaking sees glass, a light, and the possibility of an audience whose members remain largely unknown.

Both sides may experience something relational. What they know about each other is nevertheless profoundly different.

“Z’jip Reflection — Why Modern Online Connection Feels So Intimate” enters To Them as a personal reflection from the author behind Intend to Relate. That distinction belongs at the beginning. L’republique Z’jip’s experiences influence the work, but the author and the project are not interchangeable. This piece considers a relationship the act of making the project has brought into view.

Something real can happen through a screen

A voice enters a private space. A listener hears it while driving, walking, or lying awake. A passage provides language for something difficult. An idea stays with the listener and changes a later decision.

The episode does not dismiss those experiences as counterfeit. Their consequences can be real even when the creator never knows who received the work. The question concerns what follows from the reality of the encounter.

Repeated exposure can make a voice familiar. A listener may learn how the author reasons or recognize themes that matter to him. That knowledge is something. It is still different from knowing what the author intends toward this listener specifically, particularly when he does not know that person exists.

The transition from “something happened” to “I know what this means” therefore deserves attention. The first statement may be well supported while the second contains an unexamined inference about reciprocity, access, or obligation.

Incomplete others on both sides

The reflection approaches parasociality through asymmetrical information. The listener receives expression, tone, ideas, and possibly personal disclosure. The creator may receive counts, retention figures, occasional comments, and silence.

Each side can fill the missing information with imagination. A listener may infer that the creator would understand them personally or share their judgment in a particular situation. A creator may infer that nobody understood or cared because no response arrived.

The symmetry of that error matters. The listener can imagine more reciprocity than exists; the creator can imagine less reception than exists. Neither inference becomes established merely because it fits the feeling of the moment.

An honest boundary begins with knowledge: what did I receive, what did I infer, and what remains unavailable? That question preserves the value of the encounter while preventing it from becoming evidence for an entire relationship that has not occurred.

Disclosure has a scope

The invitation to authenticity can make personal disclosure feel like a standing commitment. Once a creator has told one intimate story, people may expect the next chapter. A shared experience of loneliness, family, faith, or relationships can begin to feel like permission to inquire into the rest of that life.

The reflection draws a boundary around the expression actually offered. A person can disclose something without making every connected detail available. They can speak honestly without agreeing to perpetual updates or explanations.

This is a relational distinction about access and expectations. An offered story has a scope. The listener’s interest in what remains outside that scope does not, by itself, turn the remainder into a shared undertaking.

For Intend to Relate, the distinction also protects the work’s intended scale. Readers can engage with arguments, instruments, hypotheticals, and a developing philosophy without being asked to organize their participation around the author’s biography. The project may become useful in conversations that have little to do with knowing its originator personally.

A recording and a person do not occupy time in the same way

The artifact remains available while its maker changes. Someone may discover an old recording as a new encounter, even though the author has since reconsidered a claim or moved into another season of life.

From the listener’s side, the expression is happening now. From the creator’s side, it may belong to the past. Familiarity with the artifact can obscure that difference.

This does not remove responsibility for what was published. It helps identify what the listener has encountered: an expression made at a particular time, rather than the creator’s entire present self. Context, revision, and later work may matter when drawing a broader conclusion.

It also shows why the relationship between a listener and a work can develop on its own timeline. A passage can become significant long after its creation, without generating a simultaneous personal relationship with the author.

Creators can become entitled too

The reflection turns the boundary around. A creator can begin treating attention as an obligation: why did a regular listener stop, why does a follower never comment, why has someone who values the work not subscribed?

Labels can quietly supply the agreement that was never discussed. “Followers,” “fans,” “community,” and “family” may describe something people affirm together. They may also be names a creator assigns to an aggregate audience.

The band analogy returns. Writing someone’s name on an album cover does not make them a member of the band. Likewise, calling recipients a community does not establish what they have undertaken with each other or with the creator.

The boundary is bilateral. Personal disclosure does not automatically confer personal access. Receiving a work does not automatically incur loyalty, payment, public support, or continued attention. A relationship can become warmer while remaining clear about those limits.

Expectations are not automatically agreements

Recurring conduct creates expectations. A creator publishes every Thursday. Replies arrive regularly. Listeners recognize one another. Familiar language and customs begin to form.

These patterns can matter. The episode does not deny that actual undertakings may exist or that someone can fail to honor one. It asks what has been expressed, what has been assented to, and what is being supplied by convention or hope.

The phrase “invisible contract” can conceal that inquiry. It may describe expectations while implying that their terms were mutually accepted. The framework instead asks us to examine the particular understanding before treating disappointment as proof of a broken promise.

Sometimes disappointment reveals a breach. Sometimes it reveals that the parties never had the same understanding. Sometimes no shared undertaking existed at all. The emotional reality alone does not determine which situation occurred.

When does an audience become a “we”?

The project has explored movement from individual experience toward shared life, organization, and a meaningful entity. That vocabulary raises a new question here: what would make “we” a truthful description of people encountering a work?

Perhaps shared meaning develops. Perhaps recurring participation acquires structure. People may begin communicating with one another, expressing an aim, and making commitments. Something more than independent reception may take form.

Those are possibilities to examine rather than a checklist that automatically produces a community. Publishing alone does not establish them. Watching alone does not establish them either. Nor does a large count tell us whether they have emerged.

The author can hope for such participation without announcing its existence prematurely. The distinction is especially important for a framework concerned with making shared meaning explicit: its own audience should not be drafted into a collective identity by assertion.

A return signal changes what is available

The invitation at the end is specific. Tell the work something analytics cannot: what you understood, where you disagreed, what an example missed, or how a tool appeared in your own experience.

A response gives the creator something intentionally offered by another person to encounter. It does not reveal that person entirely or create unlimited mutual access. It changes the available information and may open a different kind of relating.

Quiet reception retains its value. A reader can be deeply affected without responding. The invitation offers another possibility without declaring the existing encounter inadequate.

What have we actually given each other?

That question carries the reflection beyond creator culture. A meaningful expression can be received without implying every relationship we might associate with it. A boundary can preserve closeness by making its actual scope more truthful.

For reflection, consider a creator whose work feels familiar. What do you know from the work? What do you imagine about the person? Then reverse the inquiry: where have you treated someone’s attention to your expression as evidence of an undertaking they never made?

The author’s position remains open: something may have happened here, and its meaning deserves care. What it becomes depends on what is actually offered, received, expressed, and agreed to.

Continue with Intend to Relate

Explore the framework at Intend2Relate.com, read further in the journal, and find the publications and audio. The original podcast develops the shared foundation; To Them examines the others we address, encounter, and imagine.

A question, disagreement, or account of trying an idea is welcome in the YouTube community. Speak as yourself, with something you have actually encountered. One on one, if you intend to relate.

Episode guide

Times are taken from the supplied transcript; a differently edited video may need different chapter points.


Full episode transcript

Reading copy of the full supplied transcript. Paragraphs and section headings aid navigation; minor spelling and recognition corrections are recorded in the draft’s editorial notes. This copy has not been checked against the recording.

00:00 · Author and project

Welcome back to To Them. A brief clarification before we begin. This is a little different from most of what you hear on the Intend2Relate podcast. Usually you hear the project, you hear its ideas, its models, its vocabulary, its experiments, its hypotheticals, and its developing philosophy of relationships. You do not hear very much about me, and that is intentional. I am the author behind the work. I write under the name L’republique Z’jip.

But Z’jip is not Intend2Relate. The author and the project overlap, of course. My experiences, questions, observations, and mistakes inevitably influence what gets investigated. But the project is intended to become something larger than an autobiography or a personality. What follows began as a reflection from the author. It was not originally written as the official voice of Intend2Relate. But the subject turned out to belong rather naturally inside to them. Because it concerns a relationship that I am presently trying to understand.

The relationship between a creator, a work, and the people somewhere on the other side of it. So we decided to share the reflection here too. Consider this as Z’jip stepping out from behind the project for a few minutes. Not to tell you what Intend2Relate officially thinks, but to think aloud about something the existence of Intend2Relate has caused me to encounter.

01:25 · The lens and the asymmetry

And today I want to talk about a strange relationship. Perhaps ours. Or perhaps even that word goes too far. That is part of the question. When you look into this lens, you see one person speaking directly to you. When I look into it, I see a piece of glass. Maybe a little light, and beyond that, an invisible multitude. Or perhaps no one at all. I do not know. That single asymmetry changes almost everything about what is happening here.

You encounter a person. I encounter an imagined audience. And yet both of us may experience something that feels relational. That is what I want to examine. Not to criticize it. Not to pathologize it. Not to tell you that some connection you have experienced through a screen is fake. Actually, almost the opposite. I think something real happens here. The interesting question is what kind of thing it is. Because human beings are very quick to move from something happened to I know what this means.

And those are not always the same proposition. That distinction appears throughout Intend2Relate. What happened? What did I experience? What did I infer? What did the other person actually intend? And nowhere may that distinction become stranger than when one person speaks through a screen to another person they cannot see. You may be listening in headphones. Maybe you are driving. Maybe you are lying in bed late at night. Maybe a voice enters a private space and begins to feel unusually close.

That experience can be genuine. You really are hearing me. These really are ideas I chose to express. Perhaps something I say makes you laugh. Perhaps it irritates you. Perhaps it gives language to something you have been trying to understand. Perhaps you remember it tomorrow. Perhaps it changes a decision. Those effects are real, but now we have to be careful, because from the reality of an encounter, we can very easily begin manufacturing additional realities.

You have heard my voice repeatedly. You have watched my face. Maybe you have now heard something personal. You may know some of the questions I think about. You may begin recognizing how I reason, and eventually a strange sentence becomes possible. I know him. Maybe. But what does know mean there? You know something. Potentially quite a lot. But there is still an enormous amount you do not know. Perhaps more importantly, there is something else you may not know.

What I intend toward you specifically, because I may not know who you are.

03:57 · Knowledge and inference

This is one reason I find the word parasocial interesting but insufficient. It is often used as though the basic problem is that some viewer mistakenly thinks a creator is their friend. Certainly, that can happen. But I think the more basic phenomenon comes before anything that dramatic. It begins with asymmetrical information. You receive a tremendous amount of information about the person speaking. The person speaking receives almost none about you. You hear hesitation, you notice repetition, you can infer mood, you may notice when something appears to matter.

Meanwhile, from this side, there may only be a number, 100 views, 1000 views, 37% retention, maybe a few comments, perhaps none. Those are not people in the phenomenological sense. Those are traces, signals, evidence that somebody was there. So we each confront an incomplete other. And then imagination begins helping us. You may imagine more reciprocity than actually exists. I may imagine less reception than actually exists. That symmetry matters. The viewer may think he understands people like me.

He would probably agree with me. If we met, we would get along. I know what he meant. Maybe, but perhaps not. Meanwhile, I might think, nobody cared about that. They did not understand it. That episode failed. There is no audience here. Maybe, but perhaps not. Silence does not tell me what happened inside another person. And familiarity does not tell you what would happen between us if we actually met. So perhaps the first boundary here is epistemic, a boundary around what we actually know.

I should not pretend to know you merely because I can count you. And you should not pretend to know me merely because you can see me. That does not make the encounter meaningless. It protects the encounter from meanings we have not earned yet.

05:51 · Disclosure and vulnerability

There is another boundary, vulnerability. Creators are constantly encouraged to be authentic, be real, show people who you really are, tell the story, let them behind the curtain. And there can be something wonderful about that. Vulnerability can carry meaning. A person saying something honestly can allow another person to feel less alone. But vulnerability also creates a strange expectation. Once someone has opened a door, people may begin to believe the door should remain open.

If you have told one intimate story, perhaps you should tell the next one. If you talk openly about your relationships, perhaps people are entitled to information about those relationships. If you have spoken about loneliness, divorce, faith, sex, fear, money, family, failure, ambition, whatever it might be, perhaps those subjects begin to feel like public territory. But disclosure is not a transfer of ownership. If I tell you something personal, I have offered you that expression.

That does not necessarily mean you have acquired access to the rest of me. It does not necessarily mean I owe an update. It does not necessarily mean I owe an explanation. And it does not mean the version of the author you encounter here is the entirety of the person who wrote the work. That distinction matters particularly in a project like this one. Because most of the time, you are not being invited primarily into the biography of Z’jip.

You are being invited into Intend2Relate, into the ideas, the models, the questions, the tools, the arguments, the thought experiments. The author can stand behind that work without requiring the audience to develop a personal relationship with the author. And the work can affect someone who knows almost nothing about the person who made it. That is not a defect. It may actually be part of what allows a project to become more than the personality that started it.

07:47 · The recording across time

There is another temporal complication too. A recording does not change. A person does. I might record something today and rethink it next year. You may discover it three years later and encounter it for the first time. From your side, it is happening now. From mine, it may belong to an earlier season. The artifact collapses time. The relationship does not necessarily do the same thing.

08:11 · The creator’s expectations

And this goes both ways. Creators can become entitled too. We can begin treating attention as though it belongs to us. You watched the last 10 episodes. Why did you stop? You listen every week. Why do you never comment? You say you like the work. Why did you not subscribe? You are part of this community. Wait, are you? Maybe you are. But did we ask? Did you agree? There is a tendency online to name people into relationships.

Followers, fans, community, family, members, supporters. And sometimes those descriptions are accurate. Sometimes people affirm them. Sometimes genuine communities emerge. But sometimes a creator is simply assigning relational language to an aggregate audience. Intend2Relate has already played with a related principle. Nobody becomes a member of the band merely because somebody else put their name on the album cover. And I think the same principle belongs here. So there may be an important bilateral rule.

You are not entitled to me because I disclosed myself to you. And I am not entitled to you because you received something I made. That sounds almost cold, but I do not think it is. Boundaries are often mistaken for distance. Sometimes a boundary is exactly what allows closeness to remain honest. Because without boundaries, imagination can quietly become obligation. A viewer imagines, this person has become important to me, therefore I should be important to them.

A creator imagines, these people receive my work, therefore they owe something back. Neither proposition necessarily follows.

09:48 · Expectations and agreements

And this is where I hesitate when people describe creator-audience relationships as an invisible contract. Maybe there is something contract-like about them. Expectations can form, patterns develop. A creator uploads every Thursday, people begin organizing around Thursday. A creator answers every comment, people begin expecting replies. Language develops, customs form. Maybe people begin recognizing one another, something more organized begins to emerge. But a contract suggests agreement. Intend2Relate spends quite a lot of time asking us not to confuse expectations with agreements.

What has actually been expressed? What did somebody actually assent to? What can reasonably be relied upon? What is only convention? What is projection? What is hope? Because there is a danger in silently drafting other people into agreements they never made. Digital relationships make silent drafting extraordinarily easy. You can draft the creator into friendship. The creator can draft the audience into community. The audience can draft the creator into perpetual authenticity. The creator can draft the audience into loyalty.

Nobody signs. Nobody necessarily even speaks. And yet disappointment arrives as though a promise had been broken. That seems worth examining, because perhaps some disappointments really do involve broken undertakings. But perhaps others are discoveries that no agreement existed in the first place. That brings me back to phenomenology. What actually appears? A person, a voice, an idea, a screen, a number, a comment, a silence. Then interpretation begins. An interpretation is not bad. We cannot live without it.

The problem begins when we forget that interpretation occurred, when inference quietly becomes fact. You hear me say something and think, he means X. Maybe I do, but if X becomes important enough, you may need more information. I release something and nobody comments. I think they did not care. That is also an inference. Silence contains very little semantic content. It could mean indifference. It could mean contemplation. It could mean somebody listened while driving and forgot to comment.

It could mean disagreement. It could mean exhaustion. It could mean nothing more than the platform never showed somebody the episode. So perhaps the parasocial problem does not begin with caring too much. Perhaps it begins when we fail to distinguish encounter from inference. And that is where this reflection becomes personal for me, as the author. Not necessarily for Intend2Relate as an entity or project. For me, I make this work. I release it.

I intend toward people I cannot see. And then there is sometimes quiet. The project itself has already acknowledged that strange condition, putting something into the world, hoping it will be encountered, and then experiencing the silence that follows. But this is where the author has to obey his own framework, too. I cannot turn silence into knowledge. I cannot say, no one cares. I do not know that. I also cannot say, there is a deeply engaged community out there.

I do not know that either. There is evidence of encounter, some evidence of attention, occasional return signals, and a great deal that remains unknown. That unknown space is one reason to them interests me. Them. The hoped for others. The people somewhere on the other side of expression. Some known, some partly known, some anonymous, some imagined, some perhaps not yet there. That raises a question that may ultimately belong to the project as much as to its author.

13:27 · When an audience becomes a we

When does an audience actually become a we? Intend2Relate has played elsewhere with the movement from individual experience into shared life, organization, and eventually a meaningful entity. There are the musicians. And then, under certain conditions, there is the band, there are individual participants, and then perhaps something emerges that can truthfully be called us. But merely watching does not necessarily create that. Merely publishing does not necessarily create it either. Maybe shared meaning begins forming.

Maybe recurring participation gives it structure. Maybe language develops. Maybe people start communicating not only with the creator, but with one another. Maybe there is an aim. Maybe expectations are actually expressed. Maybe commitments become mutual. At some point, perhaps something more than creator and audience emerges. But we should not announce the entity before it exists. That would be another kind of projection. So for now, perhaps the healthier description is simpler. There was an encounter.

The author expressed something. The project offered something. You received it. Perhaps you responded. Perhaps you did not. Perhaps it affected you. Perhaps it did not. We can allow the reality of that event without demanding that it become more than it was, and we can remain open to what it might become. That is where boundaries matter. Not merely as walls, as containers for truthful meaning. A boundary preserves the difference between what we actually gave each other and everything we might imagine we did.

That seems important because I want to be able to speak honestly here. I want vulnerability to remain possible without requiring the project to become autobiography. I want people to engage deeply with Intend2Relate without believing that engagement automatically creates personal access to Z’jip, and I would like the work to become part of conversations that have nothing to do with knowing its author personally. Questions, arguments, stories, disagreement, applications I never imagined. That would be a success of the work.

Not necessarily a deepening of a personal relationship with me, but I also do not want to hide behind that distinction. An author does release something of himself when he makes a serious work.

15:46 · The invitation to a return signal

So there remains an invitation, not become my follower, not join my family, not even agree with me. Something much smaller, give the work a return signal. Tell me something analytics cannot. What did you encounter here? What did you think this meant? Where did you disagree? What did it make you think about? What did the project miss? Because if I only speak and you only receive, something can still happen. But when information begins traveling back, the nature of the encounter changes.

Now I have something of you to encounter too. Not all of you, not enough to pretend I know you, but something you intentionally offered back. And perhaps that is where a different kind of relating can begin. I should not pretend to know you merely because I can count you. You should not pretend to know me merely because you can see me. But neither of us has to pretend that nothing happened here.

There was an encounter between a person and an artifact, between an author and an unknown listener, perhaps between a listener and a project that may eventually exist independently of the person who first gave it language. What any of those relationships become, if anything, depends upon what is actually offered, actually received, actually expressed, and actually agreed to. For now, that is enough. This has been a reflection from Z’jip, the author behind Intend2Relate, and now we can return to the project.

Until next time, be free and be good to each other, intentionally.

Published by Intend2Relate, LLC.