Volume One: To Him — Episode 3 | A podcast by Intend to Relate
What do you know, what do you suspect, and what have the two of you actually agreed to?
The first two episodes of To Him developed a place to stand: the Power Position of Self-Valuation, followed by its embodied expression in American Samurai Posture, Version 1.0. We began considering how to move through the world with confidence, recognize value, and assess an encounter.
Episode Three asks whether that footing holds.
It also brings the inquiry directly into relationship agreements. Sometimes our understanding needs to be tested against something outside our own thinking. Sometimes the people involved have left important expectations unspoken. Clearer communication gives us something more definite to assess.
Watch / Listen: Spotify / Youtube / Apple
Reality testing and the people we can call
The episode introduces reality testing through a basic question: do our perceptions, beliefs, and conclusions correspond to something beyond the account we are giving ourselves?
A deliberately exaggerated burning-bush example illustrates the value of another perspective. From there, the episode recommends intentionally cultivating two kinds of relationship:
- A contemporary: someone around your age or stage of life who knows you, can be reached when something is happening, and is willing to challenge you honestly.
- An older mentor: someone whose experience includes watching people, including himself, be confidently wrong.
The buddy and the elder bring different perspectives to the same task. They give us people with whom we can examine an experience, question an interpretation, and notice what we may be missing.
The invitation is to cultivate those relationships deliberately. Honest feedback becomes more available when there is already someone you can call.
How much confidence does the information warrant?
The episode borrows the term confidence interval from statistics for an informal question about the strength of our conclusions. Its use here is conceptual; no statistical interval is calculated.
The question is:
How confident am I entitled to be about this proposition based on the information I actually have?
Knowledge, strong belief, suspicion, imagination, and a story we are telling ourselves have different standing. Keeping track of those differences matters when we decide how to act.
For now, the episode introduces two positions:
Position | What it means here |
|---|---|
Settled | The evidence is sufficient to rely on the fact. Another person’s desire to argue does not, by itself, require reopening it. |
Contestable | This is a current interpretation that may be incomplete or mistaken. Missing information, another person’s account, or our own self-deception may matter. |
This gives us room to stand firmly where the evidence supports us and remain open where the interpretation is still developing. A challenge and new information are different things; the question is what either actually contributes.
Keep track of your own bullshit
The episode recalls advice from an older lawyer whom the speaker knew before law school. The warning is offered as a paraphrase:
Once you start believing your own bullshit, you are truly fucked.
The surrounding discussion makes the point precise. We can advocate a position while knowing its weaknesses. We can experiment with an idea, play a role, or use a provisional story to get through a difficult situation.
Trouble begins when we lose track of what we were doing.
A provisional story becomes a fact. A suspicion becomes something we remember as though we witnessed it. A position we adopted for a purpose becomes a belief we no longer examine.
The practice is to retain that distinction: what do I know, what do I think, and how did this proposition acquire its present status in my mind?
Divine intelligence and the willingness to be corrected
The episode then turns toward a conception of the divine as infinite intelligence.
It is introduced as an experiment in orientation. The speaker places his own limited intelligence alongside the extraordinary amount of intelligence outside himself and invites the same scrutiny he is recommending to the listener.
“Stand confidently. Know you’re an idiot.”
The humor carries a serious invitation: maintain your footing while recognizing your capacity to misunderstand, forget, and reach a bad conclusion.
The prayer that follows asks for clarity, correction if the speaker is wrong, and the ability to communicate anything useful that may be present. The framework itself remains available for reality testing.
Evolutionary explanation and relational choice
From there, the episode examines two familiar ways of talking about romance: competitive mating narratives and stories of inevitable, all-conquering love.
The concern is what happens when either story takes attention away from the actual relationship between the people involved.
The episode offers a distinction:
Evolutionary explanation is not relational prescription.
Within the framework, the natural world supplies conditions, impulses, and limitations. The business world supplies exchange, coordination, and organization. The divine world supplies meaning, ideals, and questions about what a relationship might become.
The argument is that all three matter when we choose how to participate. An account of our impulses leaves further questions about the understandings, commitments, and forms of cooperation we want to create.
The inquiry returns to the two people: what do they value, what are they trying to build, and what are they willing to offer each other?
From private expectations to shared agreements
An unexpected detour through BDSM brings the discussion to wanted behavior, limits, signals, and understandings. The speaker uses the example to observe that deliberately exploring power makes the structure of participation especially important.
From there, the questions become applicable more broadly.
What makes you feel respected or loved? What makes you want to continue participating? What behavior makes the relationship worse? What is incompatible with what you are trying to build?
And then:
Have you actually told the other person?
The episode illustrates the problem with a conversation about socializing with a former lover. Without a shared understanding, the discussion can quickly fill with questions about jealousy, trust, motives, insecurity, and what other people consider normal.
The alternative offered is a proposal. One person articulates a preference and asks whether the other will agree to it. The other person can accept, refuse, qualify the request, propose different terms, or conclude that the two people want incompatible things.
If they reach a clear agreement, they have a shared reference point. When its terms cover the conduct at issue, they can ask:
What did we agree to?
What actually happened?
Are those two things consistent?
That comparison still depends on understanding the terms and establishing what occurred. It gives the discussion something more definite than an expectation that remained inside one person’s head.
Recognizing the good as well as the difficulty
Clear agreements also help us recognize what people are intentionally creating together.
If I tell you what matters to me and you consistently participate in creating it, we can notice that contribution, value it, and build on it. Fulfilled understandings make care and cooperation more visible.
The episode keeps personal sovereignty in view throughout. A person can decline a proposal, negotiate it, leave, or agree and then act inconsistently with it. An agreement supplies a reference point while the participants retain their agency.
It can reduce some unnecessary ambiguity. Relationships still require attention, interpretation, and communication.
The episode closes by bringing the tools together: confidence gives us somewhere to stand; reality testing examines the footing; our confidence level keeps knowledge and suspicion distinguishable; and clearer agreements reduce some of what we would otherwise have to guess.
Know what you know. Know what you want. Say it. Let the other person answer. Then pay attention to what happens.
My dudes, this one is for you. Everybody is welcome.
Key Ideas
- Test your footing. Compare perceptions and conclusions with information beyond your own account of events.
- Cultivate candid relationships. A contemporary and an experienced mentor can help you examine what you may be missing.
- Keep track of certainty. The episode uses “confidence interval” informally to ask what confidence the available information warrants.
- Distinguish settled from contestable. Hold sufficiently supported facts firmly while keeping developing interpretations available for correction.
- Remember the status of your own stories. A suspicion, a useful posture, and an established fact require different treatment.
- Bring explanation back to choice. Accounts of human impulses leave room to decide what kind of relationship to build.
- Give the other person an actual proposal. Articulate what matters, invite an answer, and establish what is mutually understood.
- Recognize fulfillment as well as inconsistency. Agreements can make intentionally created value easier to see.
Full Transcript
Prepared from the episode’s automatically generated transcript and lightly edited for punctuation, readability, and apparent transcription errors. Speaker labels have been removed; paragraph breaks, section headings, and navigation timestamps have been added. The opening series label and self-valuation terminology have been standardized to match Volume One: To Him.
00:00 — Relational Reality Checks
All right, my dudes.
Welcome back to Volume 1: To Him Forthcoming, a podcast by Intend to Relate. This is our third episode. Let's pick up where we left off.
Last time we started building out what I called the American Samurai Posture, Version 1.0. We started from a position of power—not power over somebody else, but power in the sense of having somewhere to stand.
Self-valuation, confidence.
We used the stop sign as a heuristic. We looked at tangible experiences and things in the world. We started separating what we know, what we think, what we want, and what is actually happening around us.
And we looked at our three worlds: the natural world, the business and transactional world, and the divine world.
Today we're going to keep building from there, but we're going to do it in manageable steps.
Because here's the problem.
You can get your heuristic of confidence. You can stand up straight. You can feel strong. You can say, “I know who I am. I know what I believe. I know what I'm doing.”
Great.
But does your footing hold up?
That's where reality testing comes in.
The buddy test
For right now, I don't want to make reality testing complicated. We're just talking about the basic idea that sometimes we need to check whether our ideas, beliefs, perceptions, and conclusions correspond to something outside our own head.
Because you cannot always reality test yourself by yourself.
At the simplest level, there's what I'm going to call the buddy test.
“Hey dude, do you see that bush burning?”
“No, it's just a bush.”
“You don't see fire?”
“Nope.”
“Okay, there's no burning bush.”
We've reality tested. I was hallucinating the burning bush.
Now, obviously, that's an exaggerated example. I'm not saying that every time something confusing happens in your relationship, you immediately call your buddy and ask him to adjudicate it. We're starting more basically than that.
I'm talking about a survival-level structure. You should have a dude you can go to.
The buddy and the elder
Actually, this framework would recommend you intentionally develop a two-level relational structure for this kind of check-in and reality testing.
One is the contemporary. Somebody around your age or stage of life who knows you, who isn't afraid to tell you when you're full of shit, and who you can call contemporaneously.
“Hey man, something weird happened.”
“Hey, I'm drinking too much.”
“Hey, I don't think I'm thinking clearly.”
“Hey, I think I'm hearing things.”
Whatever it is.
And then I think you should have somebody else, if you can find him: the older mentor. Somebody with more experience than you, somebody you respect, somebody who has lived long enough to have watched people, including himself, be very confidently wrong.
That gives you a two-tier reality testing structure.
The buddy and the elder support structure for a dude is one this framework recommends you intentionally build and cultivate.
Not everybody has that, but I think it's worth cultivating.
03:02 — Confidence Intervals
Now, let's add another tool.
I'm going to borrow a term from statistics, but I'm not doing statistics here. The term is “confidence interval.”
In statistics, that has a precise mathematical meaning. That's not what I'm claiming to calculate. I'm borrowing the language to ask a much simpler question:
How confident am I entitled to be about this proposition based on the information I actually have?
Because we get ourselves into trouble when everything in our head has the same status. It doesn't.
There are things I know. There are things I strongly believe. There are things I suspect. There are stories I'm telling myself. There are possibilities I'm entertaining. And there is some bullshit.
Those are not the same thing.
For right now, I'm going to give you two positions at opposite ends.
Settled
The first is settled.
I know what happened. I saw it. The evidence is sufficient. I'm not reopening the underlying fact merely because somebody wants to argue with me about it.
If I watch you walk outside, get into a blue Honda and drive away, I'm not going to spend the next three hours debating whether you left in a red Ford.
I saw you. That's settled.
And this is important because reality testing doesn't mean surrendering every fact you know every time somebody challenges you.
That's not humility. That can become its own kind of insanity.
Contestable
But then there's another position: contestable.
This is what I think happened. This is my best interpretation right now, but I might be missing information. I might be wrong.
They might be bullshitting me, or—I need to leave this possibility open—I might be bullshitting myself.
04:38 — Avoid Self-Deception
And that brings me to one of the most useful pieces of advice I ever got.
Before law school, I worked at a bookstore, and there was this older lawyer who I met and talked with. Super nerdy, wildly intelligent kind of older dude.
He knew way more than books. Had opinions, of course, but stories, knowledge—just fascinating.
Later, I learned he'd spent his career with the CIA. Then a lot of things made more sense.
I've been fortunate that I have cultivated relationships with experienced, intelligent older men. I like questions and I ask questions, and I question older people as well.
And sometimes, if you can sync up with somebody who has spent 50 or 60 years accumulating knowledge, they will just start dropping it on you.
And this guy gave me one gem I offer you here—a rule. I'm paraphrasing him, but the rule was basically this:
Once you start believing your own bullshit, you are truly fucked.
Think about that.
A lawyer may advocate a position while knowing exactly where its weak points are. A negotiator may posture. A spy may literally be playing a role. You might be experimenting with an idea. You might tell yourself something temporarily because you're trying to get through a situation.
The danger isn't merely that some bullshit entered the system. The danger is that somewhere along the way, you forgot it was bullshit.
The provisional story became a fact. The posture became a belief. The suspicion became a memory.
And now you're inside it.
You have lost track of the truth because you lost track of your own confidence level.
So that's the rule.
Know what you know. Know what you merely think. And never forget which one you're dealing with.
06:21 — Divine Intelligence
Now we're gonna talk about God for a minute.
Call me on my shit here. I'm experimenting.
First, I want to assert something about myself.
I'm a fucking idiot, dude. I am. I'm just some fucking guy trying to figure things out.
And you're an idiot too.
I know what it's like to be a human being. We get brain fog. We get tired. We misremember things. We read something 80 times and forget it. We get emotional. We misunderstand each other. We confidently reach stupid conclusions.
I didn't invent most of the things I'm working with here. I'm building on the shoulders of giants.
I have some intelligence. You have some intelligence. But there is an extraordinary amount of intelligence outside either one of us.
And somewhere in 20th-century American literature, I encountered a conception of a higher power that stuck with me: infinite intelligence.
I'm not asking you to adopt that as your theology. I'm not even trying to do theology right now. I'm offering it as a conception.
Because in a technological, data-driven 21st-century world, intelligence is an interesting attribute of the divine to contemplate. And it gives us a useful posture.
Stand confidently. Know you're an idiot.
Those two things are not inconsistent.
So before I go any further, I'll make the experiment myself.
God of infinite intelligence, please give me the grace to speak about this clearly.
And if I'm wrong, let the world reality test me. If I'm mistaken, let somebody show me.
And if there's something useful here, help me express it clearly enough that somebody else can see it too.
07:58 — Beyond Evolution
All right, let's go.
I think we are living inside some badly confused narratives about romantic love.
On one side, we have this evolutionary psychology language: male mating strategy, female mating strategy, sexual competition, reproductive success, winning the game.
On the other side, we have this almost religious but often completely secular idea: he's the one, she's the one, forever and ever. Love conquers everything.
And sometimes neither side seems particularly interested in describing the actual relationship happening between the two people standing there.
So here's a distinction I want to offer.
Evolutionary explanation is not relational prescription.
Evolutionary biology may help explain things about us. Fine, we are animals, we have bodies, we have drives, we have inherited tendencies, we have competition. That's the natural world.
But we do not live exclusively in a state of nature.
Human beings spent thousands of years building institutions, systems, governments, markets, laws, religions, technologies, and systems of order.
Whatever you think about the particular results, that changes the environment in which we relate.
I don't have to defeat another man in physical combat to take his resources and reproduce. Thank God.
We have property, we have exchange, we have law, we have constitutional rights, we have freedom of association, we have agreements. We have ways of organizing cooperation among sovereign individuals without reducing every human encounter to natural competition.
That's part of what I mean when I talk about the three worlds.
Nature gives us conditions and impulses. The business world gives us exchange, coordination, and organization. The divine world gives us meaning, ideals, orientation, and the possibility of asking what something ought to become.
Law creates a great deal of the civilized space in which we can choose how we participate in all three.
So I'm not telling you that you have to reject nature, and I'm definitely not telling you the government should legislate my relationship philosophy onto you.
Quite the opposite.
I'm saying you're sovereign, you're free. You can decide how civilized or uncivilized you want your own relational life to be.
But if you intentionally adopt an uncivilized model inside a civilized society, don't be shocked when you repeatedly produce uncivilized results.
And if you want more order, meaning, clarity, and predictability in your relational life, you're allowed to create some.
10:31 — Agreements Clarity
Even the brat has a structure
That brings me, weirdly enough, to BDSM.
I've played around with personality tests and roles in that world, and I consistently come up high on primal dominant and brat tamer.
And yeah, that tracks.
A brat tamer. There's the brat behavior, there's the pushback, there's the discipline, there's the play.
But here's the interesting thing for our purposes.
Even the brat has a structure.
Even in a relationship deliberately playing with power exchange, discipline, provocation, control, whatever, the existence of power doesn't eliminate structure. It makes structure more important.
There are things that are wanted, there are things that aren't wanted, there are limits, there are signals, there are understandings, there is participation.
So let's take the kink out of it for a second.
As a man, what behavior do you actually value in somebody you're relating to?
What do you like? What makes you feel respected? What makes you feel loved? What makes you want to continue participating?
And then, what don't you accept? What makes the relationship worse? What makes you withdraw? What do you consider incompatible with what you're trying to build?
Forget whether anybody else thinks your answers are correct for a second. Do you know your own answers?
Because once you know them, we get to the next question.
Have you actually told the other person?
Reality test me
Let's make this concrete.
Your buddy calls you.
“Hey man, reality test me. She's telling me she got called into something with work and afterward everybody's going out for drinks. She says it's nothing personal, but Bobby's gonna be there. She used to date Bobby. I don't like that shit. Am I being crazy? Am I overthinking this?”
Now we're in it.
What did she mean? What's Bobby doing? Is he jealous? Is she lying? Is my buddy insecure? Should he trust her? What's normal? What's controlling? What's appropriate?
We've got 12 propositions floating around, and now we're calling a third person to help figure out what the hell reality is.
Compare that with this:
“Hey babe, you used to date Bobby. I'm not comfortable with either of us privately socializing with former lovers. I wouldn't do it to you either. Would you agree that we're not gonna do that?”
She can say yes, she can say no. She can say, “That's ridiculous.” She can say, “I'll agree to this, but not that.” She can make the same request of you.
You can negotiate, you can decide you're incompatible. All of those remain possible.
But suppose she says, “Yes, that's fine. I agree.”
Now we have something different.
We have an object in the world: an agreement.
And if she goes and does the thing anyway, notice how much epistemic fog disappears.
I don't need to call my buddy and ask whether I'm allowed to feel jealous. I don't need to determine whether Bobby secretly wants her back. I don't need to diagnose anybody.
I have much simpler questions.
What did we agree to? What actually happened? Are those two things consistent?
That's it.
Agreements and freedom
And that's where all of these pieces come together.
The purpose of relationship agreements isn't to control another human being. They can't.
The other person remains sovereign. They can refuse your offer. They can negotiate it. They can leave. They can even agree and then violate the agreement.
An agreement doesn't eliminate freedom.
What it can eliminate is some unnecessary ambiguity, and that's important because sometimes we think we need more reality testing when what we actually needed much earlier was clearer communication.
What do I value? What do I dislike? What am I asking for? What are you offering? What are we agreeing to? And what actually happened?
For the good, this helps us recognize the good.
If I tell you what matters to me, and you consistently participate in creating it with me, I don't have to treat that as an accident.
We can recognize it. We can value it. We can build on it.
And for the bad, it can reduce some of the fog, the gaslighting, the confusion, the anxiety, the endless interpretation, the call to the buddy, the call to the therapist, the argument over whether the thing that happened even counts as the thing that happened.
We're not going to eliminate all of that.
Relationships are complicated because human beings are complicated, but we can make reality easier to see.
The Samurai Toolkit
So that's what we're adding to the Samurai Toolkit today.
Confidence gives you somewhere to stand.
Reality testing asks whether the ground is real.
Your confidence level reminds you what you know and what you merely suspect, and clear agreements reduce the number of things you have to guess about in the first place.
Know what you know, know what you don't know, know what you want, say it, let the other person answer, and then pay attention to what actually happens.
That's enough for Episode 3.
Until next time, be free and be good to each other, intentionally.
Related Concepts
The Power Position of Self-Valuation; American Samurai Posture; reality testing; the buddy and the elder; confidence levels; settled and contestable propositions; self-deception; divine intelligence; the natural, business, and divine worlds; personal sovereignty; relationship agreements; shared understandings.
For the starting point of this inquiry, read Episode One: Heuristics of Confidence and the Default Rule of Assessment. Episode Two, American Samurai Posture, Version 1.0, brings those ideas into an embodied orientation.
Join the Conversation
What is one expectation you have treated as understood in a relationship without ever asking whether the other person actually agreed to it?
To Him is the podcast accompanying the development of the forthcoming first volume of the Intend to Relate canon. It speaks directly to men and welcomes everyone interested in the inquiry. Explore Volume One: To Him.
Intend to Relate develops a philosophy and toolkit for approaching relationships intentionally: understanding ourselves, articulating aims, encountering other people’s intentions, and giving participation a more deliberate form.
Become a free member, sign up for updates, and get Relationship Agreements and Conflicting Understandings: A Primer from the member Library. Two complete stories with short analysis. No paid subscription required.
Content note: Explicit language and frank discussion of adult relationships. Philosophical and educational commentary, not individualized legal, medical, or mental-health advice. Relationship agreements do not replace ongoing consent.
Published by Intend2Relate, LLC.
Be free, and be good to each other - intentionally.