Looking back at Volume 8: To America — Season One, I see a subtle error in my choice of language that mattered more than I initially appreciated.
I used “dipshit” where “bullshit” would have better expressed what I intended to challenge. I cuss like a sailor despite my education, upbringing and blessings, and I can get confrontational in argument against opponents I view as dangerous or substantially in the wrong. But, I could have done better.
“Dipshit” refers to the person. “Bullshit” refers to what is being said: the claim, the argument, the explanation offered as justification. The difference is small in wording, but substantial in the relationship it establishes with the subject—and with the audience.
From the beginning, the terminology gave the season an attacking tone. Before the reasoning had even begun, the framing had already delivered a judgment about people. I see that more clearly now.
At one point, I said that taking the time to develop and put out material against racism was, in part, a public service. I meant that. Examining the assumptions, contradictions, and consequences of racist ideas is worthwhile work.
I was also having fun with it.
Those things coexisted. The seriousness of the subject did not make the humor insincere, and enjoying the work did not erase its purpose. But enjoyment of ridicule can affect the work itself. It can make the insult feel like part of the argument, even when it contributes nothing to demonstrating why an argument fails.
That is where I think my framing went wrong. I wanted to expose faulty reasoning, yet the language invited an encounter organized around contempt for the people expressing it.
This distinction matters within Intend to Relate’s own work. If we ask people to examine their assumptions, distinguish persons from propositions, and become more deliberate about how they relate, those principles also apply to the way we present our criticism. They apply especially when we feel confident that the criticism is justified.
“Bullshit” is hardly gentle language. Replacing one word with another would not, by itself, have resolved the issue. An argument still needs to identify the claim, explain what is wrong with it, and make its reasoning available for examination. The profanity cannot do that work.
My objection to racism remains. So does my belief that confronting its reasoning can serve a public purpose. Looking back, I would have given that work a different opening posture.
A subtle error in language can set the tone for everything that follows. In this case, I think it did. That is a correction I owe the work—and a useful reminder to myself about the relationship between what I intend and what I actually put into the world.
Member discussion: